We are often asked to describe the differences and similarities between Leveled Literacy Intervention (LLI) and Guided Reading. While guided reading is an essential element of the instruction presented in LLI, the program itself is not a "Guided Reading program" because of the instructional contexts it is used in. Both Guided Reading and Leveled Literacy Intervention provide reading instruction with an emphasis on language learning, but they differ in the following ways:
General Context: Instruction with emphasis on language learning
Guided reading: Guided reading is one component of a comprehensive language and literacy framework for instruction. Across many contexts, students receive instruction in reading comprehension, phonics/word study, and writing. Guided reading specifically helps students develop proficient systems for strategic actions for reading.
LLI: Leveled Literacy Intervention is a systematically designed, sequenced, short, supplementary lesson that builds on high-quality classroom instruction. It includes reading, phonics, and writing about reading. LLI offers intensive instruction to help struggling readers develop proficient systems of strategic actions for reading.
Instructional purpose:
Guided reading: Differentiated classroom instruction
LLI: Supplementary literacy intervention
Students served:
Guided reading: All students
LLI: Readers who are having difficulty and are reading below grade level
Student grouping:
Guided reading: Small group instruction - usually 4 to 8 students. Students are placed in groups because they have similar instructional levels.
LLI: Small group instruction - 3 to a maximum of 4 students per group for upper grades. Students are placed in groups because they have similar instructional levels.
Duration of instruction:
Guided reading: Ongoing across elementary school years
LLI: Temporary, short-term intervention (10 to 20 weeks, with possibility of more if needed)
Instructional materials:
Guided reading: Leveled books selected by the teacher for the group
LLI: Leveled books that are designed for Leveled Literacy Intervention lessons and placed in a preplanned sequence
Assessment:
Guided reading: Benchmark assessment to determine instructional level for each student. Beginning of the year, interval, and end-of-year data recorded. Interval assessment varies.
LLI: Benchmark assessment to determine instructional level for each student. Entry, interval assessments, and exit data recorded. Interval assessment data collected every other day (1 reading record every 6 days for reach student)
Time required:
Guided reading: 15 to 20 minutes varying from 3-5 times per week (more for students who are having difficulty)
LLI: 30 minutes daily (stretching to 45 minutes for upper elementary grades)
Instructional framework:
Guided reading: Guided reading lessons include:
- Text selection
- Text introduction
- Reading with teacher support and interaction
- Discussion of the meaning
- Teaching point
- Word work (optional)
- Extending the meaning (optional)
LLI: Even-numbered lessons include:
- Preparation (text analysis; goals)
- Rereading and assessment
- Phonics/word work
- Writing about reading (instructional text from yesterday)
- Reading a new text (independent level)
- Classroom and Home Connection
LLI: Odd-numbered lessons include:
- Preparation (text analysis; goals)
- Rereading text
- Phonics/word work
- Reading a new text (instructional level introduction, reading, discussion, teaching point)
- Word work
- Classroom and Home Connection
Instructional elements:
Guided reading:
- Books matched to readers to support efficient processing and good comprehension
- Comprehension supported by introduction, discussion, and specific teaching
- Fluency explicitly taught and prompted
- Writing about reading used as an option to extend comprehending
- Phonics/word study demonstrated, taught, and reinforced during reading and taught in specific teaching points after reading - word work at the end of the lesson is optional
- Vocabulary build through encountering new words in texts
- Motivation fostered by selecting engaging texts and matching books to students' current reading levels
LLI:
- Books matched to readers and carefully sequenced to support efficient processing and good comprehension
- Comprehension supported by introduction, discussion, and specific teaching
- Fluency explicitly taught and prompted; rereading assists fluency; reading a new book at independent level also supports fluency
- Writing about reading used every other day to extend comprehension
- Phonics/word study is preplanned, sequenced, and explicitly taught twice in every 30 minute lesson
- Vocabulary built through encountering new words in texts
- Motivation fostered by selecting engaging texts and matching books to students' current reading levels; series books (fiction and nonfiction) build engagement; books not in classroom use
Teacher materials:
Guided reading: Professional books (see Fountas & Pinnell at Heinemann.com), Fountas & Pinnell Prompting Guide 1
LLI: When Readers Struggle, Fountas & Pinnell Prompting Guide 1, Lesson Guides
Professional development:
Guided reading: Professional books, professional development sessions, literacy coaching in classrooms where available
LLI: Specific 6-day training at The Ohio State University and Lesley University, built-in professional development lessons and guides, DVDs demonstrating lessons and routines, tutorial on reading records
Teacher:
Guided reading: Classroom teacher
LLI: Intervention, reading specialist, or classroom teacher